Magmasaur
A volcanic creature that smelts metal in its inventory. Must be raised from stolen eggs. Immune to lava damage.
Full Magmasaur wiki pageARK creature comparison
Magmasaur vs Carbonemys
Side-by-side ARK creature comparison: stats, traits and which is better.
Carbonemys
A slow but extremely tanky turtle. Great for early-game water exploration and soaking turrets.
Full Carbonemys wiki pageThe Verdict
Overall winner: Magmasaur
Magmasaur comes out ahead on raw power (score 60/100, tier B) and wins 4/5 compared stats.
Stat wins: Magmasaur 4 – 1 Carbonemys. Auto-generated summary computed from base stats — a community estimate, not an official ranking.
Stat-by-Stat Comparison
| Stat | Magmasaur | Carbonemys | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diet | Carnivore | Herbivore | — |
| Temperament | Aggressive | Passive | — |
| Tameable | No | Yes | — |
| Rideable | Yes | Yes | — |
| Health | 3000 | 700 | Magmasaur |
| Stamina | 500 | 200 | Magmasaur |
| Oxygen | 200 | 150 | Magmasaur |
| Food | 2000 | 3000 | Carbonemys |
| Weight | 550 | 270 | Magmasaur |
| Melee Damage | 1 | 1 | Tie |
| Movement Speed | 1 | 1 | Tie |
| Torpor | 725 | 275 | — |