Skip to main content

ARK creature comparison

Carbonemys vs Magmasaur

Side-by-side ARK creature comparison: stats, traits and which is better.

Carbonemys

Carbonemys

A slow but extremely tanky turtle. Great for early-game water exploration and soaking turrets.

Full Carbonemys wiki page
Magmasaur

Magmasaur

A volcanic creature that smelts metal in its inventory. Must be raised from stolen eggs. Immune to lava damage.

Full Magmasaur wiki page

The Verdict

Overall winner: Magmasaur

Magmasaur comes out ahead on raw power (score 60/100, tier B) and wins 4/5 compared stats.

Stat wins: Carbonemys 1 – 4 Magmasaur. Auto-generated summary computed from base stats — a community estimate, not an official ranking.

Stat-by-Stat Comparison

StatCarbonemysMagmasaurWinner
DietHerbivoreCarnivore—
TemperamentPassiveAggressive—
TameableYesNo—
RideableYesYes—
Health7003000Magmasaur
Stamina200500Magmasaur
Oxygen150200Magmasaur
Food30002000Carbonemys
Weight270550Magmasaur
Melee Damage11Tie
Movement Speed11Tie
Torpor275725—

More creature comparisons

Wiki & tools

DodoReaperDodoReaper

The ultimate gaming platform — the complete wiki, server lists, mods, tools, hosting & community for Survival Evolved & Ascended.

Join our Discord
Copyright & Disclaimer

Wiki and mod data are extracted from game files using the ARK Data Extractor and cross-referenced with the ARK Wiki (ark.wiki.gg) for reference and verification.

ARK: Survival Evolved and ARK: Survival Ascended, including their names, trademarks, artwork, images, in-game assets, and other protected materials, are subject to the intellectual property rights of their respective owners and rights holders, including Studio Wildcard and other applicable rights holders.

DodoReaper is an independent, fan-made platform and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Studio Wildcard, Wildcard Properties LLC, Snail Games USA, Inc., or their respective affiliates.

Mod-related data, images, and assets may be subject to the intellectual property rights of Studio Wildcard, individual mod creators, or other rights holders. All third-party intellectual property rights remain with their respective owners. References to third-party products, games, or content do not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by their respective owners.

If you have any questions or concerns regarding content published on DodoReaper, please submit a support ticket. We take content-related requests seriously and will review them promptly.

Our mission is to help players explore the game, provide useful tools and resources for players and developers, and contribute to the growth of the ARK community.

© 2026 DodoReaper. All rights reserved in our original content, software, design, and materials, to the extent permitted by law. All third-party intellectual property rights remain with their respective owners.